After Nathan is shot by Future Peter, Peter Petrelli and Matt Parkman chase after him. Future Peter runs into a bathroom and Peter runs in first. Matt then walks in and there is only one Peter in the room. It is then later revealed that Future Peter teleported Peter into the body of Jesse Murphy in Level 5 who shouts "I'm Peter Petrelli!"
|Level 5 Escapees|
| Free: Noah Bennet | Flint Gordon | Howard Grigsby | Baron Samedi|
Deceased: Stephen Canfield | Echo DeMille | Dennis | The German | Jesse Murphy | Maury Parkman | Danny Pine | Benjamin "Knox" Washington
Recaptured: Eric Doyle | Michael Fitzgerald | Tina Ramierez